Executive Function and Academic Performance: Why EF and SEL Skills Matter More Than You Think

The Student Who "Should Be" Doing Better

Let me guess. You have at least one student right now who's confusing you.

They're clearly capable. They participate in discussions. They understand the concepts when you explain them. But when it comes time to actually do the work? Something falls apart.

Maybe they can't get started. Maybe they rush through and make careless mistakes. Maybe they shut down the second something gets hard. Maybe they're disorganized, distractible, or constantly arguing with peers during group work.

And you've probably thought: "If they would just focus..." or "They're smart enough, they're just not trying..."

Here's what's actually happening. Academic success isn't just about intelligence or effort. It's built on a foundation of skills we don't talk about enough: executive function and social-emotional learning.

What Executive Function Actually Means (and Why It Matters)

Executive function isn't one skill. It's a collection of mental processes that help us plan, focus, remember instructions, manage emotions, and juggle multiple tasks.

Think of it as your brain's management system. It includes things like:

• Working memory (holding information in your mind while you use it)

• Flexible thinking (adjusting when something doesn't go as planned)

• Self-control (managing impulses and emotions)

• Planning and organization (breaking tasks into steps, keeping track of materials)

• Task initiation (actually getting started instead of staring at a blank page)

When these systems work well, students can follow multi-step directions, stay focused during independent work, recover from mistakes, and organize their materials and thoughts.

When they don't? That's when you see the "smart kid who can't get it together."

And here's the critical part: research shows that executive function and academic performance are more closely linked than we ever realized. In fact, studies have found that executive function skills are often better predictors of school success than IQ scores.

Where Social-Emotional Learning Fits In

Now add social-emotional skills to the mix. Self-awareness. Self-management. Social awareness. Relationship skills. Responsible decision-making.

These aren't "soft skills" that are nice to have. They're essential for learning.

A student needs self-awareness to recognize when they're confused and ask for help. They need self-management to calm down after a frustrating math problem. They need relationship skills to work effectively with a partner. They need responsible decision-making to choose strategies that actually work for them.

Here's where it gets interesting: executive function and SEL aren't separate. They're deeply interconnected.

Self-control is both an executive function skill and an SEL competency. So is emotional regulation. So is flexible thinking when you're working through conflict with a peer.

When we support one, we're often supporting the other. And when students struggle with both, academic performance takes the hit.

What This Actually Looks Like in the Classroom

Let's get concrete. Here are real scenarios you've probably seen:

• The student who can't start an assignment isn't being defiant. They might be struggling with task initiation (an executive function skill) or feeling overwhelmed and lacking the self-management strategies to break through it (an SEL skill).

• The student who rushes through work and makes careless mistakes might have weak self-monitoring skills (executive function) and lack the self-awareness to recognize their own patterns (SEL).

• The student who falls apart during group projects might struggle with flexible thinking when plans change (executive function) and need more support with relationship skills and perspective-taking (SEL).

• The student who gives up the second something gets hard might not have developed frustration tolerance (self-management) or the metacognitive awareness to try a different strategy (executive function).

See the pattern? Academic struggles often aren't about not understanding the content. They're about not having the underlying skills to access, process, and demonstrate that understanding.

Why Traditional Academic Support Sometimes Misses the Mark

We're really good at addressing content gaps. If a student doesn't understand fractions, we reteach fractions. If they're struggling with reading comprehension, we work on comprehension strategies.

But what if the real issue isn't the fractions or the reading passage?

What if the student can't hold multiple steps in their working memory long enough to solve the problem? What if they can't manage their frustration when the answer doesn't come quickly? What if they lack the planning skills to organize their thoughts for a written response?

Reteaching the content won't fix that. We need to address the executive function and SEL foundation.

The good news? When we do, everything else gets easier. Students don't just perform better academically. They become more independent, more resilient, and more confident learners.

How Executive Function and Academic Performance Intersect in Real Life

Understanding the connection between executive function and academic performance changes how we support students. Instead of just asking "Do they understand the content?" we also ask "Do they have the EF and SEL skills to access and demonstrate that understanding?"

Here are some starting points:

• Notice patterns, not just behaviors. When you see a student struggling, get curious about the underlying skills. Is this a working memory issue? An emotional regulation challenge? A planning problem? Understanding the root cause changes your intervention.

• Teach the skills explicitly. Don't assume students know how to plan, organize, manage frustration, or advocate for themselves. These skills need to be taught just like academic content.

• Build support into your classroom structure. Visual schedules support planning and organization. Brain breaks support self-regulation. Think-alouds model metacognition. Collaborative routines build relationship skills. You're probably already doing some of this—now you know why it matters so much.

• Talk about thinking and feeling. Help students develop metacognitive awareness by naming what's happening in their brains. "I notice you're having trouble getting started. What usually helps you take that first step?" or "You seemed frustrated when that didn't work. What could you try differently?"

• Celebrate growth in these skills, not just academic outcomes. When a student who usually gives up keeps trying, that's worth celebrating. When a disorganized kid remembers to bring their materials, notice it. These wins matter.

The Bottom Line

Academic success isn't just about what students know. It's about whether they have the executive function and social-emotional skills to organize their thinking, manage their emotions, work with others, and persist through challenges.

When we only focus on content and ignore the foundation, we're building on shaky ground. But when we understand how executive function and academic performance connect, and when we intentionally support both EF and SEL development, we're setting students up for real, sustainable success.

Not just in school. In life.

---

Want practical tools for supporting executive function and SEL in your classroom?

Join our newsletter series where we share weekly strategies, observation tools, and free resources designed for real educators working with real students. We're breaking down the science and giving you what you can actually use tomorrow.

Join the Learning Community